Communication Log

Home»Corporate Governance»Functional Committee»Communication Log

Communication between Audit Committee, Independent Directors, and the Chief Internal Auditor:

  • • After submitting the audit report and follow-up report, the Chief Internal Auditor hands over audit items for review to all independent directors before the end of following month. Should independent directors be interested in further understanding of the status of the audit and follow-up results, they would contact the Chief Internal Auditor at any time. The Chief Internal Auditor would sit in board meetings to report the audit findings and to answer questions. Accountants maintain good communication with each audit committee member and would also sit in board meetings to answer questions when necessary.
  • • Aside from attending Audit Committee meetings and answering questions, the Chief Internal Auditor also had separate interviews with each independent director. A total of four interviews were held in FY2023. At the interviews, the Chief Internal Auditor reported the audit progress and details regarding audit implementation. Summaries of interviews are as follows:
  • Items Description Names of independent directors interviewed, time of interview, and suggestions
    Hung Ching Lee Dr. Pisin Chen Su-Pi Shen
    2023/06/02 &
    2023/12/08
    2023/09/08 2023/03/14
    Description of
    the audit plan
    Audit plan for the parent company and each
    subsidiary for the current year was submitted
    to the independent directors for review and
    suggestion on additional audit items.
    NA NA NA
    Description of
    work progress
    Describe audit team’s auditing items,
    methods, and progress prior to the review
    meeting.
    NA NA NA
    Description of
    audit progress
    • Audit plan was submitted to the independent
    directors for review.
    • As of the end of this interview, some areas of
    improvement have been found for the current
    year’s audit, the audit team has proposed
    suggestions for rectification and requested
    relevant departments to act accordingly; no
    major flaws were identified.
    NA NA NA
    Other
    discussion
    items
    • Suggestions or items that require further
    attention in auditing.
    Inquired about a news article
    reported on 2023/11/08
    regarding a former employee
    stole other employee’s identity to gain entry access to the plant and committed an act of theft.
    Further inquired about reasons
    behind the theft act and the
    Company’s counter-measures.
    After listening to the
    explanations, Mr. Lee
    recommended that the audit
    team should continue to track
    the status of implementing the
    proposed improvement plan.
    NA NA
    • Other recommendations or corrections to be
    made.
    NA NA NA
  • Related works have been enclosed in the annual audit plan, as well as the regular and irregular execution items. No significant anomalies or violations were found during the annual audit this year. Therefore, there was no matter to be reported to independent directors immediately.

Communication Between Independent Directors and Accountants:

    Date Attendees Communication Items Explanation From Accountants
    2023/08/11 Independent Directors:
  •   Hung Ching Lee
  •   Dr. Pisin Chen
  •   Su-Pi Shen

  • CPA:
  •   Tsao Jen Wu
  •   Shu-Ling Lien

  • Chief Internal Auditor:
  •   Pei-Ming Chen

  • Internal Audit Officer:
  •   Tracy Li

  • Finance Center:
  •   Chao-Chin Hsu
  •   Hsin-Yi Chien
  • CPA Mr. Wu:
    • Abbreviated
    description of annual
    financial audits and the direction of amendments to relevant regulations.
  • • The direction of this quarter’s regulations update focuses on Corporate Governance 3.0 and relevant disclosure of ISSB
    ESG.
  • • Regarding the adoption of Taiwan CFC rules in 2023, the
    impact on Quanta is not material after discussing and
    assessing the impact with relevant finance and accounting
    departments at Quanta. As Quanta has prepared and planned
    in advance, relevant liabilities were already recognized in P&L.
  • • Government around the world is promoting the Global
    Anti-Base Erosion (GloBE) rules, however, the implementation is still under discussion due the complexity nature of the rules. Only European countries have more contrate versions, while
    implementation around the world is still pending on regulations. KPMG will continue to monitor and provide more detailed
    updates once initial draft of regulations become more contrate and clear.
  • Independent Director
    Ms. Shen:
    • Please elaborate on amendments to IAS
    (International
    Accounting Standard) 1, 8 and 12 adopted in
    FY2023.
  • • Amendments to IAS 1 focuses on the disclosure of
    accounting policies. Most countries, including Taiwan, tend to
    include standard accounting policies in the disclosure, which
    not only increases costs but also reduces the effectiveness of
    financial statements disclosure. For the purpose of reducing
    costs of preparing financial statements and to increase the
    value of information disclosure, the amendments would require entities to only disclose material accounting policies that are
    relevant to business operations and applicable items.
  • • IAS 8 is the definition of accounting estimates, and to clarify
    the differences between accounting policies and accounting
    estimates. Changes in an accounting policy are applied
    retrospectively, while changes in accounting estimates are
    accounted for prospectively.
  • • IAS 12 is on income taxes, recognition of deferred tax related to assets and liabilities arising from a single transaction would have greater impact. Following the amendments, entities are
    required to simultaneously recognize deferred tax related to
    assets and liabilities in the balance sheet.
  • Independent Director
    Mr. Lee:
    • Would amendments to IAS have material
    impact on Quanta’s
    financial reports?
  • • No material impact on Quanta’s financial reports is expected. Amendments to IAS 1 have already been adopted in the
    current financial reports, while amendments to IAS 8 and IAS
    12 should not have material impact on Quanta.
  • Independent Director
    Mr. Lee:
    • Various industries and companies are facing
    labor shortages and
    rising costs post COVID, is there a significant
    impact or adjustments
    on your firm’s allocation of auditors to Quanta?
  • • Labor shortages is a common issue faced by various
    industries and companies, KPMG has adjusted our service
    teams accordingly during COVID, including the utilization of
    electronic, paper-less, and online processing. We further
    accelerated the effectiveness of computer auditing work in
    order to lower the burden of manual operations.
  • • On the other hand, in response to the rising trend of auditing, as the majority of companies’ financial data is gradually relying on the ERP system, our accounting firm has also established a designated team to adopt computer auditing and ERP auditing in order to lower audit risk and operation costs.
  • Independent Director
    Mr. Lee:
    • As Quanta gradually
    establishes subsidiaries around the world, how
    does your firm manage
    the auditing task?
  • • KPMG would prepare annual auditing plans in advance for
    each fiscal year and classify auditing plans in accordance to
    the operation scale and significance of each subsidiary of an
    audited company. For areas of greater significance, we would
    discuss with the company on dividing audit tasks, then
    appointing Taiwanese or local accounting firms to perform the
    auditing works. To ensure the quality of auditing works, we
    would provide auditing procedures to local accountants to
    ensure its annual auditing quality complies with the auditing
    regulations and standards of Taiwan.
  • • In Quanta’s case, areas in China and the U.S. have greater
    significance at the present time. China is the main
    manufacturing operation site, while the U.S. is both sales and manufacturing center.
  • • Auditing work during COVID was partially replaced by online
    review or inquiries. We plan to increase on-site auditing post
    COVID, especially for areas of greater significance, we will
    conduct on-site review of audit workpapers prepared by local
    auditors to ensure the auditing work adhere to the auditing
    standards provided by us. Currently, areas of our auditing
    focus are in China and the U.S., while we will also consider
    conducting on-site audits of subsidiaries in South East
    countries as areas of great significance due to increased
    investments and production in the region.
  • Independent Director
    Mr. Lee:
    • Are all local auditing
    firms franchises of
    KPMG?
  • • Most of the subsidiaries are audited by our firm, but
    subsidiaries in some areas are audited by local accounting
    firms. Auditing of subsidiaries in China is conducted by
    ShineWing International, which has been cooperating with our
    firm for many years and is also one of the eight largest CPA
    firms in China. To ensure auditing quality, we would review
    their audit workpapers. Most of the reviews have been
    conducted over the Internet in recent years due to COVID, and we plan to resume on-site reviews and audits as the pandemic gradually eases off.
  • • Auditing of subsidiaries in the U.S. is conducted by local
    accounting firms, while our firm is still responsible for the
    annual audits. Since the majority of financial and accounting
    data is already uploaded to the ERP system, our firm would
    also perform on-site audit aside from online audits.
  • Introduction of new
    accountant.
  • • Accountant Lien:
    Hello, everyone, I joined KPMG in 1993 and Quanta was my
    very first client at the time. After becoming a certified
    accountant, Quanta was also the first company that I audited
    and attested its financial statements, so you can say that I
    practically grew with Quanta. I thus am very familiar with
    Quanta’s business operations, finance and accounting
    operations, as well as reviewing and auditing businesses.
    During my time at KPMG, I was once transferred to Shanghai
    office responsible for the auditing work between Taiwan and
    China. I feel honored to have the opportunity to service Quanta once again after several rounds of function rotation.